BBC: 5 years on from Covid; lockdown countries vs. non lockdown

An analysis of how things worked out in various countries with various rules. And of course various systems from extreme harsh lockdowns to virtually none at all – and everything in between. And the results are … mixed.

It's a long analysis.

While these case studies of various countries show that it was clearly possible to tackle the Covid-19 pandemic without resorting to national lockdowns, the end results seem to depend on the attributes of specific countries, their populations, and their healthcare systems. Ultimately, the vast majority of nations did enact lockdowns at some point during 2020 or 2021 and it would be hard to suggest that they are all significantly worse off because of that intervention, specifically.

Still, five years later, the harshness of lockdowns and their effects on millions if not billions of people has become clearer. Even some researchers who have found evidence that lockdowns saved lives have cautioned against turning to this measure in haste in the future. The longer-term effects on children, education and economies are still playing out and will likely not be fully understood for many years to come.

Whatever governments decide to do, having a plan that they communicate in advance of any new pandemic will likely improve public acceptance of and adherence to any strict mitigations, says Grout. "It needs to be super clear." That means everyone could know ahead of time what circumstances would trigger a lockdown.

In Gothenburg, Mc Manus remembers the debates she once had with her fellow Swedes over whether her country was doing the right thing in 2020. And how some people seemed cavalier or uninterested in observing social distancing guidelines at the time.

"You don't even talk about it anymore," she says, "Thinking back, I feel like, as a society, did we really learn anything from this?"


Comments

2 responses to “BBC: 5 years on from Covid; lockdown countries vs. non lockdown”

  1. Valeria Kondratiev Avatar
    Valeria Kondratiev

    In my experience of the response to Covid in the US, especially here in NY, I saw common sense being thrown out in favor of crazy authoritarian rule. Of course, in Europe, where I have family and friends, the authoritarian rule was even worse and the common sense even more absent. The common sense approach, which could have saved lives of vulnerable people without damaging social life and livelihoods, would have been to stay home when sick, and protect the elderly and vulnerable people. Isolating healthy people, especially youth and children was useless and damaging for them. I really hope the next response to any proposal of lockdown is NEVER AGAIN!

  2. YES!

Leave a Reply to Maria Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *